Pelski’s ‘Best 2008 Summer Festival ‘ poll results


A couple of weeks ago I asked ‘Which is the best 2008 Summer Festival?’

With 427 votes cast… Pukkelpop is the winner with 138 votes – 32%.

Pukkelpop
138 (32%)
Gatecrasher Summer Soundsystem
80 (18%)
Glastonbury
42 (9%)
Creamfields
32 (7%)
Global Gathering
29 (6%)
Bestival
28 (6%)
Benicassim
24 (5%)
Sonar
24 (5%)
Glade
13 (3%)
Exit
12 (2%)
O2 Wireless
5 (1%)

Festival season has come to an end…ah.. a summer in which suncream and sun-hats were wasted investments, while umbrellas and rain coats were wise ones. After all, over 38 British festivals had to be canceled this year. Festivals are surreal experiences – perhaps entirely down to the strange congregation of reprobates… all jumping around a soggy field. There’s a bizzarre assemblage of the new rave (and clearly underage) wankers, the lager-swilling lads, the middle-class stoners, the fleuro-trance sluts, the moronic ‘jokers’ dressed in impractical cow costumes, the hardened old school ravers, and the many, many pill-troopers all on a mission to grind their teeth into oblivion. It’s strange to think that that pissed-up, half-naked lad climbing the tent scaffolding, intermittently showering the crowd below with vomit, will – within 24 hours – be back at work behind a desk, neatly dressed in shirt and tie…

Pukkelpop

But when choosing which is the best, it’s important to weigh up four vital factors – the line-up, venue, organisation and atmosphere. The most important, in my opinion, is the line-up. So my vote too went to the Belgium festival Pukkelpop. I’ve been to Pukkelpop once in 2006 at the very reasonable price of £60 for three days. It helps that this year it had the best line-up of the bunch. To name a few:

  • 2many DJs, Benga, Blood Beetroots, Boys Noise, Brodinski, Count & Sinden, Crookers, Diplo, Deadmau5, Does It Offend You, Yeah?, Dusty Kid, Erol Alkan, Headman, Junkie XL, Late Of The Pier, Midnight Juggernuahgts, Modeselektor, SebastiAn, Shakleton, The Shoes, SMD, Soulwax, The Subs, Surkin, The Whip, Yelle, Yuksek.

Furthermore, being somewhat more obscure than the rest of the festivals (and because it’s overseas): there are fewer people; there’s more space to dance; and it’s easier to get right up front. But that’s not to say it’s baron or small – it has an excellent atmosphere – 152,000 attended this year.

Gatecrasher

The only festival that could rival Pukkelpop’s formidable line-up was Gatecrasher. And while Gatecrasher was a great festival this year, it didn’t exactly tick the boxes when it came to organisation. The second day gave way to chaos and confusion, after the mainstage was flooded. In order to prepare for a British festival, you must prepare for rain. They did not and so we had to miss out on Chemical Brothers and Hot Chip. Gatecrasher’s saving grace was the Turbo Tent – with storming sets from Proxy, Erol, Boys Noize, Justice, Tiga, Brodinski and SMD. Gatecrasher deservedly came in 2nd place in the poll with 80 votes – 18%. My full review here.

Glastonbury

With half the votes of Gatcrasher, Glastonbury won third prize. I’m not sure why. It’s the loyalists really; the ones who attend year after year; the ones who step through the gates sighing “ahhh back at Galstonbury, home, sweet home” (or probably have some affectionate nick-name for it like “Glasto” or “The ‘Bury). Fair enough. People have an affiliation with it and since it’s so large your likely to find something you want to watch. The only problem is getting there – many of the stages are a half hour walk apart, made even more arduos by the gluey mud. But for all the talk of a crappy line-up, Jay-Z went down well and there were some decent dance acts to be seen. For me though, it’s just too big. And it’s still getting bigger (this year they added the ‘Flagtopia’ field).

Creamfield & Global Gathering

Creamfields vs Global? Both fairly mediocre line-ups, though Creamfields probably just wins out. I learnt how poorly organised Global was last year. The stewards are unhelpful and there was only one cash-machine to cater to 70,000 people. A slightly hostile atmosphere hung over the Global.

Bestival

Bestival has a similar ethos to Galstonbury – chilled, friendly and lots of assorted entertainment. I attended Bestival this year, and yes, the mud was atrocious. But the whole experience was great fun. Though I don’t feel I can assess it in terms of music (thanks in part to a fake timetable and some hazy memories). A-trak’s set was certainly the highlight though, showing-off some nifty turntable skills that included a short history of hip hop, expertly mashed together. The atmosphere is alot more friendly than the likes of Creamfields and Global Gathering. I remember walking around Reading aged 16 and genuinely fearing for my life. At many festivals you feel out of your element. Bestival you do not. It was a pleasant and quirky festival – a welcome change.

Glade

Now… Glade’s never been my cup of tea. And in front of my ‘Gladeite’ friends I’ve always denounced it, writing it off as “a goddamned hippie-fest, where druid-like ravers hallucinate wildly – clad in tie-dye and hemp – hold hands and form circles, and leap around to bongo drums”.
Apparently it’s not all like this.
There’s also alot of excellent techno on show. And these days, as I find myself turning to the more alternative and minimal spheres of dance, I’d certainly like to give Glade a go. The line-up had some real treats:

  • Atomic Hooligan, Claude Von Stroke, Daedalus, Drop The Lime (who didn’t actually make it – thanks to his driver putting diesel in a petrol car), Dubfire, Elite Force, Klaus Hill, Meat Katie, Plump DJs, Rico Tubbs, Stanton Warriors, Tomb Crew, Vitalic.

I may go to Glade next year, if only to see ‘DJ Scotch Egg’.

——————————————————————————————–

Next year, I advise getting out of this country. Somewhere hot, like Spain’s Benicassim or Serbia’s Exit. Alternatively, if you can’t get enough of the festival feeling, book your tickets for Belgium’s superb ‘I Love Techno’ in time for November. The line-up is incredible: I Love Techno Lineup.

I’ll see you at Pukkelpop next year. I’ll be down the front (probably moaning about how cold and wet I am… only to do it all over again the next year).

PLEASE COMMENT BELOW WITH YOUR THOUGHTS…
  • Anonymous

    i just wish something decent like pukkelpop would come to australia..we only get festivals half that size.

  • http://ppelectro.blogspot.com/www.myspace.com/elektronixnl Ward Mevis

    The Pukkelpop-camping is a disaster.. if you compare it to dutch festivals like Pinkpop..
    The lack of space is idiotic…

    But nice festival indeed… but don’t think you really got that much space to dance, since de booming of boys noize, crookers and the whole electro scene the last few years are there way to much boring-i want to show my lightningshoes-kids which don’t really contribute in a good atmosphere..

    but it’s still nice though..

    also i went to I <3 Techno.. which has a few big fails as well... thinking about heat and a really really realllllly small venue comparing to it's visitors.
    Good atmosphere thought. but also the same problem as the kids on pukkelpop..

    last year i saw the first kids with big pupils or korsakoff-syndrome carried away at 22:30 hours :) ..

    anyway… they line up compensates a lot :)

    i rather heave a festival like Nature One of Sonne, Mond, Sterne

  • jade@onemoredisco

    I’ll definately be heading to Pukkelpop next year, I watched some videos of SebastiAn, Brodinsk and Surkin from this year and it looks TOO good, lets hope the line-up next year will be as impressive

    you coming to ILT this year Pelski, we’re getting the bus up from Paris, should be an adventure !

  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/08588842777885487813 Lady Beaver & Sir Domo

    Great post! Just to let you all know, KadmusArts.com is a super resource for all festival goers. They’ve got an exhaustive database of international music, theatre and dance festivals, along with a public forum where you can find out what people are saying about past and future festivals. It’s a really useful resource for festival fans and writers.

  • office worker

    haha im THAT guy showering the crowd with vomit!

  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/10690887714336932027 Copper Tallis

    I think that line up wise pukkelop definately wins, but as pelski mentions there’s a lot more to a festival than the line up, i think if going on best all round experience the results would be very different, for example Exit festival is set in an old fortress with a dance arena in an old moat in serbia. Gatecrasher came 2nd but it was a shambles, i went and experienced the slack security and horrific weather, not to mention headline acts being cancelled and someone dying in one of the tents.

    I love techno is looking like a very good option if you can affod it though.

  • Zjurre

    Where’s Sziget festival, Boedapest, Hungary? Saw some awesome Dj’s there, as well as other acts.

    Dutch greetings,

    Zjurre

  • http://telrunya.wordpress.com/ telrunya

    I’ll see you at I love techno :) I’m lucky enough to live in Belgium!

  • Vanished

    yeah Belgium is the best country to live in for electro-parties & festivals :D

    seen D.I.M. & Sound of Stereo last Friday. The Partyharders and Radioclit yesterday

    Next stop: Bangers in Bruges with The Proxy & Les Petits Pilous for a silly 8 euros (cettavous.be)

    I Love Techno will be banging to!

  • Anonymous

    You have changed your tune a bit re: Glade. I appreciate it.
    Love one of your Hippie raver friendsXx

  • http://www.myspace.com/youandmedeejays Pieter

    Belguim is one of the worldleaders in dance festivals. I’m from belguim, but i have to admit, 60 ponds seems a bit less for 3 days.

    I think that the price has grown forcely when we are talking about going out (party’s, festivals…) in Belguim.
    For example Rock Werchter: One of the biggest festivals in Europe (not far from the capital of Belguim), if you want to go for 4 days, you have to pay at least 200-250 €…
    Not a small sum hu?!

  • Is_Kill

    thanks for introducin me to joe and will ask? really likin their tunes. black holes are soundin quite good as well, but why do so many producers make their tunes with weedy 40 second intros, i wanna mix longer than that!!
    as for the festivals, u need to get urself upto rock ness in scotland. best festival iv been to, really good party atmosphere and amazin djs!

Pelski: Music News & Reviews © 2025 All Rights Reserved

Designed by Louis Louis (Real Talk Digital)